Sunday, March 30, 2014

cdma2000 CSA radio test measurements

Recording the test results from CSA radio test measurements, whether the transmission technology be e.g. GSM, CDMA, WCDMA and/or LTE, it is perhaps a common thought that the data can be output and presented in a uniform format irrespective of the transmission technology. That would be all well and good were it the case that there had been set down an agreement for CSA regarding the components that only need to be provided. However, there is no such formal forensic best practice, evidential regulation or legislative directive that prescribes this. The fact that there is lack of agreement isn't such a problem and is probably a good thing because the components acquired for CSA are constantly evolving and changing and therein, for anyone conducting CSA, is the requirement to constantly and continuously identify:

a0 - The relevant transmission technology(ies) under investigation (MS may use several cellular technologies)

a1 - The relevant transmission capability of the mobile terminal and the profiling of any (U)SIM/R-UIM

a2 - The relevant technical capability of BSS/BTS and arrangements defined at a particular mast/tower

a3 - The relevance of any legacy technology/influences operating at the material time

a4 - How the above impacts on the information that is recorded in the call records/cell site details

Where cdma2000 1x, cdma2000 1x EV-DO or cdma2000 1x EV-DV might be in use it may be that cross-referencing the radio test measurement results to corroborate the information recorded in the call records might nor always be possible. Moreover, depending upon the information dissemenation, it can be a law enforcement officer, private investigator or court/attorney the person to whom their enquiries are made for information that person may have no clue what information is available or have a limited understanding.

For those conducting cell site analysis, the identification of cell coverage and each cell's parameters detected at a particular point within a surveyed land-parcel is an important procedure. Commonly, a person conducting CSA within a cdma2000 radio demesne might seek network operator identity, radio area network identity, base station identity and cell/sector. There are various cdma standards, but for the purposes of this discussion the combination of detail that can be preferred is the combination of SID/NID/base_id/Ref_PN. I use the reference cdma2000 standard adopted for this discussion:

3GPP2 C.S0022-A v1.0 Date: March 2004
Position Determination Service for cdma2000 Spread Spectrum Systems

Provide Pilot Phase Measurement Page 2-55
2.2.4.2.6 Provide Pilot Phase Measurement (‘0101’)
If RESP_TYPE is equal to ‘0101’ (Provide Pilot Phase Measurement), RESP_PAR_RECORD shall include the following variable-length record:

Table Page 2-56




This standard defines an MS to capture and compile the SID/NID/base_id/Ref_PN along with other details but the standard does not specify how this information may be translated so that a CSA examiner can illustrate the uniqueness of a particular cell/sector. It is known that an important component for CSA that the examiner endeavours to report the cell and sector upon which MS mobile communications may be/have been routed from a particular location within a land-parcel.

Balancing the issues of the material time technology vis-a-vis legacy technology; a useful starting point appears to be June 2004 when the CDMA mobile industry focus groups discussed and reached a consensus that the inclusion of SID/NID/base_id/Ref_PN would provide the broadcast parameters for identifying a unique cell/sector. That is in relation to Position Determination Services. From my research library of historical reports and papers I note:

Terry Jacobson (Lucent Technologies) comments in X.P0024 (June 8th 2004) ".....this contribution recommends that the Pilot PN information be used (in addition to the SID, NID and BASE_ID) to uniquely identify a cell/sector. Specifically, that the REF_PN parameter be added (see C.S0022-A v1.0 page 2-53) to the SID, NID and BASE_ID as the parameters that identify the serving cell/sector. The REF_PN is a 9-bit information element indicates the “PN sequence offset of the pilot used by the mobile station to derive its time reference, relative to the zero offset pilot PN sequence in units of 64 PN chips”." 

Ref-PN as stated in 3GPP2 C.S0022-A v1.0 Date: March 2004



 So at what point would an MS communicate the measurements to the network? The standard set outs:

 
CSA examiners should read the relevant paragraphs of 3.2.2 as it reminds examiners of issues associated with 'not supported' in legacy technology.  Moreover, take care when considering what information is being measured in Idle Mode, Mobile Originated Call (send call) and Mobile Terminated Call (received call).

Subject to the collection of location components identified in this discussion actually being supported by the various technologies highlighted above, it is clear that it is possible for MS to collate the measurement results in order to send those measurements to the network. This suggests the test handset used for any radio test measurements should be able to display the combination of SID/NID/base_id/Ref_PN that should assist the examiner identify a unique cell/sector of a particular mast/tower.

The above discussion is not definitive and does not cover every aspect of cdma2000 cell site analysis. The discussion highlights one area of knowledge that may be helpful to a possible investigation by a CSA examiner.

Sunday, March 16, 2014

Examples of Cell Site Details


Here, too, it is possible to echo the discussion about passing on information: see Range of radio test measurement results - http://cellsiteanalysis.blogspot.co.uk/2014/03/range-of-radio-test-measurement-results.html






Range of radio test measurement results

I ridiculous as this may read, until I started publishing at my various blogspot I didn't realise that hoarding information is actually NOT a very good idea. Mark Twain once said (my paraphrase) 'the best thing to so with information is pass it on'. A reference to the fact that the older the information becomes the less useful it can be. I have equally found that during disucssion and debate it quite often occurs the other party will deny something not because they have knowledge and/or experience but rather the lack of them. Maybe the ruse is get research without doing any work or alternatively the person genuinely lack knowledge and experience thus didn't believe certain information existed.

Whilst it is useful to compile test results and keep them to yourself it is equally more important to the peer group to circulate such information at a point in time and space. This is important relevant to the analogies often quoted in life about (a) living on one's laurels and (b) the grass growing under one's feet.

Some good examples where sharing information is far better than keeping it yourself.

1. In a court of law the chance to present alternatives is lost in a one-chance-presentation if prior disclosure has not been made.

2. The chance to form common ground with one's peer's is yet another example

3. As a third example, what about actually knowing what type of information is available. Do remember some love the idea of psychological smoke and mirrors. However, forensics, the law of evidence, universities and education are poor for it for those the system that indulges "bluff". Also, bluff has no place in forensics and evidential standards. 




























Test your USIM knowledge

Below is UST (USIM Service Table) 3GPP 31.102 that may be found in a UST elementary file.

QUESTION 1
There are at minimum 1,900 items for examination discovery, investigatory leads and evidence that can be obtained from these UST entries.  Can you identify just 50 items for examination discovery, investigatory leads and evidence? If so, what are they?

Service n°1: Local Phone Book
Service n°2: Fixed Dialling Numbers (FDN)
Service n°3: Extension 2
Service n°4: Service Dialling Numbers (SDN)
Service n°5: Extension3
Service n°6: Barred Dialling Numbers (BDN)
Service n°7: Extension4
Service n°8: Outgoing Call Information (OCI and OCT)
Service n°9: Incoming Call Information (ICI and ICT)
Service n°10: Short Message Storage (SMS)
Service n°11: Short Message Status Reports (SMSR)
Service n°12: Short Message Service Parameters (SMSP)
Service n°13: Advice of Charge (AoC)
Service n°14: Capability Configuration Parameters 2 (CCP2)
Service n°15: Cell Broadcast Message Identifier
Service n°16: Cell Broadcast Message Identifier Ranges
Service n°17: Group Identifier Level 1
Service n°18: Group Identifier Level 2
Service n°19: Service Provider Name
Service n°20: User controlled PLMN selector with Access Technology
Service n°21: MSISDN
Service n°22: Image (IMG)
Service n°23: Support of Localised Service Areas (SoLSA)
Service n°24: Enhanced Multi Level Precedence and Pre emption Service
Service n°25: Automatic Answer for eMLPP
Service n°26: RFU
Service n°27: GSM Access
Service n°28: Data download via SMS-PP
Service n°29: Data download via SMS CB
Service n°30: Call Control by USIM
Service n°31: MO-SMS Control by USIM
Service n°32: RUN AT COMMAND command
Service n°33: shall be set to '1'
Service n°34: Enabled Services Table
Service n°35: APN Control List (ACL)
Service n°36: Depersonalisation Control Keys
Service n°37: Co-operative Network List
Service n°38: GSM security context
Service n°39: CPBCCH Information
Service n°40: Investigation Scan
Service n°41: MexE
Service n°42: Operator controlled PLMN selector with Access Technology
Service n°43: HPLMN selector with Access Technology
Service n°44: Extension 5
Service n°45: PLMN Network Name
Service n°46: Operator PLMN List
Service n°47: Mailbox Dialling Numbers
Service n°48: Message Waiting Indication Status
Service n°49: Call Forwarding Indication Status
Service n°50: Reserved and shall be ignored
Service n°51: Service Provider Display Information
Service n°52 Multimedia Messaging Service (MMS)
Service n°53 Extension 8
Service n°54 Call control on GPRS by USIM
Service n°55 MMS User Connectivity Parameters
Service n°56 Network's indication of alerting in the MS (NIA)
Service n°57 VGCS Group Identifier List (EFVGCS and EFVGCSS)
Service n°58 VBS Group Identifier List (EFVBS and EFVBSS)
Service n°59 Pseudonym
Service n°60 User Controlled PLMN selector for I-WLAN access
Service n°61 Operator Controlled PLMN selector for I-WLAN access
Service n°62 User controlled WSID list
Service n°63 Operator controlled WSID list
Service n°64 VGCS security
Service n°65 VBS security
Service n°66 WLAN Reauthentication Identity
Service n°67 Multimedia Messages Storage
Service n°68 Generic Bootstrapping Architecture (GBA)
Service n°69 MBMS security
Service n°70 Data download via USSD and USSD application mode
Service n°71 Equivalent HPLMN
Service n°72 Additional TERMINAL PROFILE after UICC activation
Service n°73 Equivalent HPLMN Presentation Indication
Service n°74 Last RPLMN Selection Indication
Service n°75 OMA BCAST Smart Card Profile
Service n°76 GBA-based Local Key Establishment Mechanism
Service n°77 Terminal Applications
Service n°78 Service Provider Name Icon
Service n°79 PLMN Network Name Icon
Service n°80 Connectivity Parameters for USIM IP connections
Service n°81 Home I-WLAN Specific Identifier List
Service n°82 I-WLAN Equivalent HPLMN Presentation Indication
Service n°83 I-WLAN HPLMN Priority Indication
Service n°84 I-WLAN Last Registered PLMN
Service n°85 EPS Mobility Management Information
Service n°86 Allowed CSG Lists and corresponding indications
Service n°87 Call control on EPS PDN connection by USIM
Service n°88 HPLMN Direct Access
Service n°89 eCall Data
Service n°90 Operator CSG Lists and corresponding indications
Service n°91 Support for SM-over-IP
Service n°92 Support of CSG Display Control
Service n°93 Communication Control for IMS by USIM
Service n°94 Extended Terminal Applications
Service n°95 Support of UICC access to IMS
Service n°96 Non-Access Stratum configuration by USIM
Service n°97 PWS configuration by USIM 


QUESTION 2
An officer approaches you as the expert to investigate comminucations on an iPhone. There is known comms that have taken place but the twist is the comms at the distance end are being received by a Satellite phone. The user of the SatPhone is known to be trafficking in young children snatched from parents whilst on holiday. Your job is to provide evidence to help the police officer regarding which elementary files in the USIM would be used to permit mobile network usage (home and roaming) and any network artefacts that maybe connected to Satellite comms? To help you, a link below leads you to a piece of equipment that links iPhone to satellite:

www.thuraya.com/

Saturday, March 15, 2014

SIM Test Card Hardware Layouts










15/11/97
Interface for ASIM

README       This file.
EMUSIM.BMP   Artwork of Smart Card sized PCB
MAX232.BMP   Artwork of Smart Card sized PCB whith MAX232
MAX232LY.GIF Parts placement guide of max232 pcb.
CIRCLAY.GIF  Parts placement guide.

The bitmap file can be loaded into Windows Paintbrush then printed. They
are drawn 1:1 at 300 dpi so make sure you click "Use printer resolution" and
the Laser printer is set to 300 dpi before you print. The artwork is drawn as
seen from the copper side. It can be printed on a transparency as is and used
directly in a positive photo etch. The copper side of PCB not touches the
toner side of transparency.

Bye
by Giulio Cesare



SIM/USIM Research Materials

Research Materials
I shall be posting material (example below) I have gathered from my research over the last 20 years that students, examiners and experts may find of use. Some of the materials to be posted I couldn't find when I searched the Internet recently. Whether that is down to me not searching enough or information held in web-based wall-gardens or the information is no longer available, it would be a pity to let that research fade into obscurity. Where I can identify authors of materials posted I shall do so. But if I cannot do that then by posting I am not declaring someone elses work or their material are my creation. I am just sharing what is and in some case what was freely distributed over the years. 

Trial and Error
When considering historical material it can provide a useful background insight, whilst at the same time nuture the interest to experiment and offers a knowledge base that may be needed or useful to know when approaching trial and error tests/experimentation.

Past Solutions Future Answers
One last point. A re-occuring theme, when considering digital evidence or forensic methodology or, even, how to apply examination techniques, is that solutions to problems, conundrums or perceived diametrically opposing facts can often be found by studying early developments in particular technologies. The approach that the manufacturer applied to the technology or how research and application found another way through may provide the solution for students, examiners and experts.

TEST SIM Script
(NOTE: The only details I have for the Author "brka". The email and website are no longer active. It is possible that the test materials are compiled from different sources and brought together in one source file. Some of the materials seemed to be have recognisable or at least similar designs to that created by the known programmer/developer "Dejan"). 

Once when you make TEST SIM using test_sim.hex you can:

          Entering into TEST mode
        ***********************

Insert TEST SIM in your phone.
Power ON phone.
When phone ask for PIN, type 5555
Then, the phone displays "CHECK CARD",
and then Power-Off the phone and Power-Up
The phone will enter into the TEST mode ....
(it can Register on ANY network ... but no Phone calls
can be done)

          Entering into CLONE mode (SP Unlocking)
          ***************************************

Insert TEST SIM in your phone.
Power ON phone.
When phone ask for PIN, type 1111
Phone will display "CHECK CARD"
Wait for few seconds and turn OFF phone!!!
Now turn phone ON and phone will be in CLONE Mode!

Clone Mode works on all Motorola phones!


          SP Unlocking
         ************

Once you are in Clone Mode, type  03# and phone will be unlocked.
NOTE!  SP unlocking work on all Motorola phones made before Sep.98!!!
It even works on some of CD920 and CD930 ....

Try it and please write me the results ....
(I found that the phones that IMEI ends with 0 can be unlocked !)

TEST SIM can be made with PIC 16F84 (16C84) wafer card.






***************************************
test_sim.hex
***************************************
This test file is still available on the internet

Tools
PICkit - http://www.microchip.com/Developmenttools/ProductDetails.aspx?PartNO=PG164130

Propic2 Clone - http://cuteminds.com/index.php/en/propic2










BYOD risks and minefields

I read the article in CIO Think_Deleted_Text_Messages_Are_Gone_Forever_Think_Again and the discussion that rumbles on about BYOD.

Firstly, a bit surprising the article suggests a "wow" factor associated with recovering deleted text messages. I would have thought it was common knowledge by now in business, generally, and particularly at CIO level.

Secondly, the notion and practice of companies getting employees to use their own devices (BYOD) to access company networks and company information seems to be an open invitation to allow a security breach (intentional or by accident) to happen. The corporate body and individual (at senior level) duty of care place encumbent obligations on both to conduct risk assessments, identify company assets, control dissemenation of company information in order to protect. It might be there are legal risks for companies demanding access to employees phones to go through their personal data.

There appears no persuasive technical/technological evidence to support BYOD propagation on the basis without it a company could not operate. Moreover, why require BYOD policies, practices and procedures that in essence generate further and continuing costs to maintain them anyway whereas in-house company devices (properly controlled) also means retention of company assets, devices have an asset value, depreciation allows for write down and tax relief etc.

BTW the points about assets and finance came from a specialist corporate accountant in this area where as accounting is not my forte. Mind you, brain surgery is not my forte either as I could not get any practice in the subject matter due to the patients; there was a shortage of volunteers.

Saturday, February 08, 2014

Smart/Mobile Devices Brand Names Listing

Examiners regularly come into contact with Brand name mobile/smart devices and the list is continuously increasing. The problem that increase creates is that there is no one website that holds a complete list.  The listing below identifies how many Brand names I have managed to harvest at this stage. I shall be updating this listing as I go along and adding useful info that examiners may find of interest.

Number - Smart/Mobile Devices Brand Names Listing

3 Skypephone


A - Smart Devices Brand Names Listing

Acer
Airo Wireless
Alcatel
Allview
Altek
Amoi
Amazon
AnexTEK
AnyCool
AnyDATA
Apple
Asus
Archos
Arnova
AT Mobile
AT&T
AU (KDDI)
Audiovox
Auro
Axia

B - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Barnes And Noble
BBK Mobiles
Bell
Bendix King
Benefon
BenQ
BenQ-Siemens
Bird
BlackBerry
Blu
Bluebird
Blumax
BMW
Bookeen
Bushnell


C - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Cal Comp
Camangi
Canmore
Casio
Cat Mobile
Cect
Celkon
Changhong
Changjiang
Cheacomm
China Mobile
Cingular
Claro
CLIE
Concord
Coolpad
Cowon
CPA
Creative
Cricket
CSL



D - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Daewoo
Dallab
Danger
Dapeng
Dell
Donod
Dopod
Doro
Duet



E - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

E-Ten
Enol
Emgeton
EMobile
Emporia
EPhone
Era
Ericsson
Eten
Ever
Everex
Evolve
Eyo


F - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Fifth Media
Firefly Mobile
Fly
Fly-Ying
Fujifilm
Fujitsu-Siemens
Fusion Garage



G - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

G-Five
G-Tide
Garmin
Garmin-Asus
General Mobile
Gigabyte
Gionee
GiSTEQ
Global High Tech
GlobalSat
Google
GPS Technologijos
Gresso
Grundig


H - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Haier
Handspring
Helio
Hertz
Hewlett Packard (HP)
Highscreen
Hisense
HKC
Holux
Hop-on
HTC
Huawei
Hyundai (Electronics)


I - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

IBM
Icemobile
I-mate
I-MOBILE
Innostream
I-node
I-teq
INQ
Insignia
iPAC
iPro
Iridium
I-teq
IzenMobile


J - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Jaga
JCB
Jincen
Jolla
JVC



K - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Karbonn Mobiles
Kendo
Kinpo
KPN
K-Touch
Kyocera



L - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Lark
Laser
Lava
Lemon Mobiles
Lenovo
Levi's
LG
Limited Label
Linx
Lowrance
Lumigon


M - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Magellan
Manta
Mappy
Maxon
MaxWest
MediaTek
Meizu
MemUp
Micromax
MIO
MiTAC
Mitsubishi
Mivvy
Mobiado
Mobin-Nova
Mobistel
ModeLabs
Modeo
Modu
Motorola
MTK
MTT
MWg
myPhone



N - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

NavGear
Navin
Navitech
Navman
NDrive
Nec
Neonode
Newgen
Nexian
Nextar
NG Mobile
Nikon
Niu
No Brand
Nokia
Nordic
NotionInk
Novogo
NTT DoCoMo



O - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

O2
Okta
Okwap
Olympus
Oppo
Opticon 
Orange
Orsio


P - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Packard-Bell
Palm
Panasonic
Pantech
Papago
Paragon Wireless
Parla
PCD
Pharos
PC-EPhone
Philips
Philips PDA
Pidion
Plum
Pocket Navigator
Prestigio
Psion
Puma


Q - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Qigi
Qool Labs
QStarz
Qtek
Quanta
Quest



R - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Rand-McNally
Reliance
Rogers
Rover
RoverPC


S - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Sagem
Samsung
SanDisk
Sanyo
Saygus
SciPhone
Sendo
Sewon
SFR 
Sharp
Siemens
SiGMATek
Sigmatel
Sim Valley
SK Telecom
SKY
Skype
Smart GPS
Socket Mobile
SoftBank
Sonim
Sony
SonyEricsson
Soutec
Spice
Sprint
Sunno
SVP
SwissCom
Sylvania


T - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

TagHeuer
Takara
Tatung
TDS
TechFaithWireless
Telecom New Zealand
Telit
Tel.Me
Telsda
Telstra
Terrestar
Thuraya
Tiger
T-Mobile
TomTom
Torg
Toshiba
Toshiba PDA
TranSystem
Turkcell



U - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Ubiquam
UBiQUiO
UMX
Unnecto
UTano
UTStarcom


V - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Velocity Mobile
Ventus
Verizon
Verzo
Vertu
VeryKool
Videocon
Viewsonic
Virgin Mobile Lobster
Visor
vivo
Vizio 
VK Mobile
Vodafone
Voxtel


W - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

WayWay
Wentto
WND


X - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

XCute
Xiaomi
XKSSTEL
Xolo
XPhoneX


Y - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Yezz
Yoo Digital


Z - Mobile/Smart Device Brand Name Listing

Zakang
ZAP
ZEN Mobile
Zonda
ZTE

Saturday, January 04, 2014

Tracing Packet Switch (PS) Users

Investigations into mobile activity tend largely to concentrate on recovering data from the user handset, mast (tower) data and call records. The core network (CN) is less well understood and therefore picking through a GSM/3GPP standard can often assist in understanding the identity and form of tarried/empheral data surviving in a network. The standard to be used for this discussion is:

3GPP TS 25.413 V12.0.0 (2013-12)
3rd Generation Partnership Project;
Technical Specification Group Radio Access Network;
UTRAN Iu interface
Radio Access Network Application Part (RANAP) signalling
(Release 12)


Now with an investigation underway initial enquiries lead to an active smartphone user operating in the pack switched (PS) domain. The target under surveillance requires the investigator to combine visual logs and the use of the of the handset. Unlike CS, packet data communications requires a range of information BUT for the purposes of the current investigation understanding the services being used and the geographical area where services are being obtained the trainee investigator can start with understanding what can be learned from:

Cell ID - Cell Identity
C-ID - Common Identity
IMEI - International Mobile Equipment Identity

IMSI - International Mobile Subscriber Identity
IPAddress - Internet Protocol Address
SAI - Service Area Identifier

SAP - Service Access Point
LAI  - Location Area Identifier
RNC - Radio Network Controller

RNS  - Radio Network Subsystem

Some examples of trainee investigation elements for consideration:

Para 8.16.1

The purpose of the Common ID procedure is to inform the RNC about the permanent NAS UE Identity (i.e. IMSI) of a user. This is used by the RNC e.g. to create a reference between the permanent NAS UE identity of the user and the RRC connection of that user for UTRAN paging co-ordination. The procedure may also be used to provide the SNA Access Information IE to the RNC or to provide the Management Based MDT Allowed IE to the RNC or to provide the Management Based MDT PLMN List IE to the RNC.


Para 8.17.2

If Trace Collection Entity IP Address IE is included and if the MDT Configuration IE is also included then the RNC shall, if supported, store the Trace Collection Entity IP address and use it when transferring Trace records, otherwise if MDT Configuration IE is not included, the RNC may use the Trace Collection Entity IP address when transferring trace records.


Para 8.35.2
When the transferred information in the Information Transfer Type IE relates to a Trace Session in the RNC, the Trace Activation Indicator IE indicates whether the Trace Session identified by the Trace Reference IE is activated or deactivated in the RNC. In case the Trace Session is activated, the Equipments To Be Traced IE gives the Equipment Identity of the UEs that the RNC has to trace. If the Trace Recording Session Reference IE, Trace Collection Entity IP Address IE, the IMSI IE and optionally the Serving Cell Identifier IE are included in the message, the CN shall take the information into account for anonymization of MDT data (TS 32.422 [10]).
 
The purpose of this brief discussion is to illustrate mobile networks naturally hold surviving data in the network for a range of reasons to enable the network to a have uniformed approach for the objective of operational performance, enquiry and, equally, to trace user terminals and roaming user terminals active in or obtaining services from a network.

Friday, January 03, 2014

FSR positioning for statutory powers

You'll need to be quick to catch this one. 

Today, 3rd January 2014, the UK Government's consultation period ends regarding seeking views on whether new powers should be given to the Forensic Science Regulator.

Decisions are to be made which will impact on mobile, digital and computer evidential collection, forensic examination, acquiring evidence etc and you will need to decide where you or your organisation fit with the whole scheme of things.

https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/new-statutory-powers-for-the-forensic-science-regulator#!

There is most likely to have been a wide range of responses from different industries and professions. One such response is the Forensic and Policing Services Association (FAPSA) and it is interesting to note that amongst its proposals they believe "high standard" is relevant. I take no issue with their stance and I am not suggesting for one moment this organisation hasn't always advocated such a stance. It is not always the case and some responses from other quarters, in the past, have suggested advocating "high standards" was to take an "elitist" attitude because 'some work to high standards and some work to low standards', which in my view was a strange stance to take regarding an individual's competency working in forensics and not in the interests of skillsets and standards to underpin forensic science.  FAPSA's stance communicates a useful message for those wanting to be or are involved with forensics science.

http://www.fapsa.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Forensic-regultaor-response-FAPSA.pdf

Another response to the consultation from Peter Sommer can be read here (see link below) and highlights some useful disparities between envisaged outcomes vis-a-vis the costs to implement them/the appropriate payment for such work:

http://pmsommer.com/HO%20FSR%20Consultation_sommer.rtf

What is clear is the need for those who never have to spend out of their own pockets should not set or allow vertical and horizontal market costs to rise by holding individuals or companies to ransom. This is quite important as there is too much reliance on the 'machine will do the thinking for me' and if my evidence and opinion is wrong then the human equation is not at fault. Knowledge, skills and experience are paramount to the work of forensic science. It is accepted devices are needed for acquisition but understanding how the device communicates with the target "thing" under examination (commonly we call this a DUT - device under test) and exactly what is being communicated to "action a command and receive a response" should be the prime facie case.

Useful examples of commands and responses can be found during the examination of mobile/smart phones. here are a few standards, but be mindful as standards extend to the air-interface (thus relevant to lawful interception etc) and mobile networks interfaces, too. 

Mobile/Smart Phones
GSM/3GPP TS 07.07 AT Command set for GSM Mobile Equipment (ME)
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/07_series/07.07/0707-780.zip

3GPP TS 27.007 AT command set for User Equipment (UE)
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/27_series/27.007/27007-c30.zip


Smart Card ICC/UICC - SIM/USIM
3GPP TS 11.11 Specification of the Subscriber Identity Module - Mobile Equipment (SIM-ME) Interface
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/11_series/11.11/1111-8e0.zip

3GPP TS 51.011 Specification of the Subscriber Identity Module - Mobile Equipment (SIM-ME) interface
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/51_series/51.011/51011-500.zip

3GPP TS 31.101 UICC-terminal interface; Physical and logical characteristics
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/31_series/31.101/31101-b00.zip

3GPP TS 31.102 Characteristics of the Universal Subscriber Identity Module (USIM) application
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/31_series/31.102/31102-c20.zip

The point of mentioning the abve standards brings the discussion back to an individual's understanding vis-a-vis the device being used against the target "DUT" and not leaving it to a machine to do the thinking.

Furthermore, it is essential to remember who is actually being 'caught in the net' under proposed changes. A response to a consultation I submitted some years ago raised the observation that if legal aid was to change regarding witness/expert fees where do organisations and scrutiny of the rules come into it where evidence is submitted directly e.g. from a mobile network operator. Never got a response on that one, but it really ought to be a fundamental requirement to identify who the FSR thinks should be excluded from his/her executive powers being imposed?

REMEMBER - DATA IS DISPASSIONATE, SO SHOULD THE EXPERT BE